There is a special quality of British political conversation that returns every few years like a particularly persistent damp patch on the ceiling. Someone of refined metropolitan sensibilities announces, with the air of a long-suffering tutor addressing a dim but well-meaning pupil, that the only cure for our current ailments is to crawl back into the arrangement we spent years prising ourselves free from. The latest outbreak coincides with Prime Minister Andy Burnham’s pilgrimage to Brussels for a “reset” summit, where the talk is of food standards, youth schemes and the vague promise of warmer feelings. Burnham has already floated the idea of rejoining in his lifetime while carefully insisting nothing so drastic will happen this parliament. The rejoiners detect the scent of opportunity. The rest of us detect the familiar aroma of institutional nostalgia mixed with selective amnesia.
The European Union that these enthusiasts wish to re-embrace is not the serene, prosperous, mildly progressive club of their fond recollection. It is a sclerotic customs union with delusions of grandeur, a continent-sized committee that requires three years of consultation to decide the correct curvature of a banana and still manages to get it wrong. Its share of the world economy continues its elegant decline while its member states specialise in the production of debt, regulation and political volatility. France, that perennial “sick man of Europe,” staggers along with growth forecasts that would embarrass a stagnant pond, budget deficits hovering around five and a half per cent, and public debt climbing towards levels that make the markets reach for the smelling salts. Germany, once the industrial powerhouse, nurses the consequences of energy policies so self-confident they border on performance art. The eurozone as a whole limps forward at a modest 1.2 per cent, while sixteen member states are expected to run deficits above the sacred three-per-cent threshold. This is the economic lifeboat into which the rejoiners urge us to leap. One almost admires the optimism.
Politically the picture is even richer. Nearly one in three European voters now backs parties classified as populist, authoritarian or extreme — a post-war record. The Alternative for Germany racks up state victories that leave the centre-right looking like a historical footnote. Marine Le Pen leads the polls in France with the serene confidence of someone who has watched the centre exhaust itself. Italy, Austria, Spain and others continue their rightward drift. The social contract across large parts of the continent resembles less a binding agreement than a set of terms and conditions that fewer citizens are inclined to renew. Borders remain porous in practice even as governments issue stern communiqués. The EU responds with the usual mixture of compulsory asylum quotas, processing hubs in distant African countries (the very idea once denounced as unspeakable when proposed by British Conservatives), and solemn warnings about “Islamist entryism.” Arguments that once marked one out as a provincial reactionary have acquired a certain Brussels respectability. Britain, it turns out, was not behind the curve so much as slightly ahead of a convoy that is now belatedly noticing the same scenery.
The rejoiners’ economic case rests on the touching belief that membership of this particular club confers automatic prosperity. Yet the practical terms of any return would be less a homecoming than a punitive readmission. The old opt-outs, the rebate, the special arrangements — all gone. Free movement restored, larger budget contributions, the probable eventual absorption into the single currency, and a thicket of rules decided by institutions that treat national electorates as an inconvenient afterthought. Polls that show abstract support for “closer ties” collapse when voters are confronted with these details. The British public, it seems, retains a residual capacity to distinguish between smoother trade and the full restoration of an arrangement whose less attractive features they have not forgotten.
There is a particular comic consistency in the Labour position. Burnham speaks of empowering the British people while contemplating the transfer of substantial authority to a highly centralised, undemocratic supranational apparatus. The same party that pursues independent trade deals, distinctive regulatory approaches and adjustments to private-school fees would find such manoeuvres considerably more difficult once locked inside the single market and customs union. One wonders whether the full implications have been absorbed, or whether the emotional satisfaction of reversing 2016 is considered sufficient compensation for the loss of actual agency.
None of this is to pretend that Brexit has been an unalloyed success. The political class that inherited the new freedoms proceeded to exercise them with a conspicuous lack of imagination, preferring high levels of low-skilled immigration and an enthusiastic regulatory apparatus to the competitive advantages that departure made available. Those failures belong to Westminster, not to the act of leaving. The remedy is not to surrender the capacity for independent action but to elect people prepared to use it — to control borders, prioritise citizens, and shape an economy that is competitive rather than merely compliant.
The rejoiners’ project is essentially retrospective. It proposes that the solution to our present difficulties is to return to a club whose own members are discovering, with increasing urgency, many of the same difficulties, only with more committees and worse public finances. Burnham’s Brussels summit is the latest chapter in this long temptation: a polite exchange of modest technical agreements dressed up as historic rapprochement. The EU, ever the needy ex, signals that further intimacy will require deeper commitment. The polite British response remains the same. No. We have seen the club’s membership terms, its declining relevance, its internal revolts and its talent for turning every practical problem into a constitutional drama. Independence may have been mismanaged, but it is still preferable to rejoining a declining bureaucracy that mistakes process for progress and treats democracy as an optional extra.