Monday, 16 November 2026

E-I, A.I, NO ...

Britain once specialised in inventing the future with the cheerful air of a nation that had nothing better to do on a wet Tuesday. The steam engine hissed into existence, railways stitched the countryside into a timetable, television brought moving pictures into the parlour before anyone had quite decided what to do with them, penicillin quietly saved lives while its discoverer remained modest about the mould, and the foundations of modern computing plus the World Wide Web itself arrived with the understated efficiency of a civil servant who had simply done the sums correctly. For a while the British appeared to regard progress as a natural by-product of mild eccentricity and a decent education.

Then something shifted. Not with a bang, of course – that would have been far too dramatic – but with the soft, insistent rustle of committee minutes and the gentle accumulation of forms in triplicate. Decades of political failure, underinvestment, EU bureaucracy and regulatory obsession arrived not as a single catastrophe but as a long, damp season in which the inventive spirit was gradually filed under “pending further consultation”. One can almost picture the scene: a bright idea appears, is examined for its environmental impact, its diversity implications, its potential to inconvenience a distant stakeholder, and is finally returned with a polite note suggesting it be reconsidered after the next election cycle.

The result is a country that now watches the AI revolution unfold with the slightly aggrieved expression of a once-great athlete who has taken up competitive form-filling. The algorithms race ahead elsewhere; the models grow more capable; the applications multiply. Meanwhile Britain, having once supplied the world with the tools to reshape itself, finds itself largely dependent on others to build the next set. There is a certain austere comedy in this. The nation that gave the world the means to compute and to communicate now specialises in the more refined art of regulating itself out of the conversation.

One need not romanticise the past. The old inventiveness was frequently messy, underfunded, and driven by individuals who would today struggle to obtain the necessary permits to light a Bunsen burner. Yet it possessed a useful indifference to the precise wording of subsection 4(b) of the relevant directive. Today the caution is almost admirable in its thoroughness. Every new capability is greeted less with curiosity than with a careful inventory of risks, followed by a lengthy process designed to ensure that no risk is ever taken. The effect is rather like equipping a racing car with so many safety features that it can no longer leave the garage without a convoy of inspectors.

The irony is sharpened by the original urgency of the discussion that prompted these reflections. Artificial intelligence is not merely another consumer gadget; it is already altering the texture of everyday systems – airspace, banking, hospitals, emergency communications – in ways that demand both competence and independence. A country that once prided itself on building the infrastructure of the modern world might reasonably be expected to insist on retaining some sovereign capacity in the technologies that now threaten to redefine security and prosperity. Instead one detects a familiar hesitation, as if the proper response to a rapidly evolving threat is another round of consultation papers.

It is, in its way, quite an achievement. From inventing the future to regulating ourselves out of it requires a special kind of consistency. The same national temperament that once produced world-changing devices now produces world-class procedures for ensuring that nothing world-changing occurs without exhaustive prior approval. One can almost admire the thoroughness. The British have not merely lost a race; they have perfected the art of arriving late while explaining, with perfect courtesy, why arriving on time would have been irresponsible.

There remains, of course, the possibility of recovery. The inventive habit is not entirely extinct; it merely finds itself operating under heavier constraints and with thinner encouragement. Whether the constraints can be eased before the dependence becomes permanent is another matter. For the moment the spectacle continues: a nation that once busied itself inventing the future now busies itself ensuring that the future arrives only after it has been properly risk-assessed, impact-assessed, and preferably invented somewhere else. The achievement is, as noted, considerable. One only hopes the historians of the future will have the paperwork in order when they come to record it.

Tuesday, 10 November 2026

CHRISTMAS, CORRECTED

There are moments in the British calendar when the national mood reveals itself more clearly than any general election. One of them arrives each November, when John Lewis unveils its Christmas advertisement. The ritual has become a kind of secular sacrament: the soft lighting, the swelling strings or, these days, the carefully curated cover version, the obligatory lump in the throat. This year’s effort, starring Dame Kristin Scott Thomas as a glamorous grandmother determined to transform her study into a glittering “Gran Cave” for her young charges, has already provoked the familiar chorus of approval from those who measure moral progress by the careful arrangement of faces on screen. Yet the response from other quarters has been rather less reverent. One particularly blunt observer noted that the old white granny appears to be ushering in her own demographic sunset, surrounded by children who look nothing like her, a Black husband figure hovering in the doorway, and not a traditional Christmas symbol in sight. The observation was crude, certainly. It was also, in its unvarnished way, difficult to dismiss entirely.

What strikes the careful viewer is not so much the presence of diversity as the studied absence of anything that might once have been called ordinary. The grandmother, elegant and faintly isolated, is granted a brief burst of manufactured joy among disco balls and tinsel streamers. Empathy, that quality John Lewis once traded in with almost embarrassing fluency, feels curiously rationed. The children’s delight is real enough on camera, but the emotional architecture supporting it feels assembled according to a checklist rather than observed from life. There is little sense of shared history, of habits passed down, of the quiet continuities that make family feel like family rather than a carefully balanced casting call. The ad congratulates itself on rediscovering the joy of giving, yet the gift it offers the audience is primarily ideological: a vision of Britain in which the old order is gently, tastefully, and irrevocably superseded.

Compare this with the reception accorded last year’s film. In 2025 John Lewis dared something almost radical in the current climate: it told a story about a father and his teenage son. A white father and a white son, as it happened, though that detail was scarcely remarked upon at the time because it seemed, for once, beside the point. The boy, awkward and headphone-clad, finds a way to speak to his father through a vinyl record of a 1990s club anthem. The father is transported back to his own youth on the dancefloor, then forward again through memories of his son as a baby and toddler, until the two of them share a slightly embarrassed, thoroughly British hug. The response was striking. Grown men admitted to weeping. Commentators spoke of masculinity, of the difficulty men have finding words, of the quiet power of a gift that says what conversation cannot. The creators themselves expressed astonishment at the warmth of the reaction. For a few weeks it felt as if a department store had accidentally produced something that looked like life rather than a seminar.

One suspects that particular experiment will not be repeated. A healthy, single-race father-son relationship, depicted without apology or corrective casting, turns out to be the sort of thing that can be indulged only once, and then only if the surrounding commentary is careful to frame it as a response to some approved cultural anxiety. The message, as currently understood in the circles that matter, requires constant visual reinforcement that the old patterns are ending. Continuity is suspect. Familiarity is exclusionary. Empathy must be redistributed according to demographic need. Last year’s ad risked suggesting that ordinary human bonds between men of the same background might still possess value. This year’s corrects the oversight with a grandmother whose primary emotional function appears to be facilitating her own cultural replacement while the camera lingers approvingly on the new arrangement.

Waitrose, meanwhile, has had the good sense to remember that Christmas advertising works best when it refuses to take itself entirely seriously. Their six-minute sequel reunites Keira Knightley with Joe Wilkinson’s endearingly shambolic Phil for a full-blown romcom of broken engagements, rival suitors and a Beef Wellington deployed as a romantic savoury exocet missile. The pair’s eventual kitchen reconciliation feels earned rather than prescribed; one detects actual affection between the performers, and a willingness to let the joke land without first consulting a sensitivity reader. It is longer than it needs to be, of course, but the excess is generous rather than preachy.

Marks & Spencer has gone further still in recovering the lost art of festive entertainment. James Norton, temporarily divested of both beard and shirt, plays an undercover Santa who slips the North Pole to sample ordinary Christmas for himself, guided by Lucy Punch’s sharp-tongued Mrs Claus. The film moves through food, fashion and domestic clutter with a light step, discovering that the real magic resides in shared meals and small rituals rather than in any grand ideological statement. There is warmth here, and a sly recognition that most people would rather watch a handsome actor (one indeed wonders if it was a secret Bond audition for Norton) pretend to be Father Christmas than sit through another sermon on the necessity of cultural replacement. The M&S advert feels almost indecently human: it invites the viewer to smile rather than to improve.

And then there is Aldi, which continues to understand that the British public will forgive almost anything so long as an anthropomorphised carrot is involved. Kevin and his daughter Chantenay set off through the snow in search of their missing Cauli Dog, only to find the creature peacefully asleep inside a Christmas cracker. The whole thing is pure, unapologetic whimsy—lost posters, mistaken bears, a child’s simple wish fulfilled. The emotion is straightforward, the humour gentle, and the resolution satisfying in the way that only a well-timed reunion of vegetable and floret can be: it assumes that audiences still possess hearts, and that those hearts prefer stories to statements.

Going back to John Lewis, the sardonic beauty of the exercise is that it is conducted with such exquisite good taste. No one raises a voice. The lighting remains soft. Kristin Scott Thomas brings her usual quiet authority. The soundtrack is tasteful. And yet the underlying proposition is stark: certain forms of belonging are no longer to be celebrated without accompanying penance. The 2025 film was allowed its moment of uncomplicated recognition because the culture still retained a residual appetite for it. The 2026 version makes clear that such appetites will henceforth be managed. 

John Lewis, once the reliable supplier of national sentimentality, has absorbed the lesson. It will not be allowed to do something like that again. The message, after all, must be protected from the dangerous possibility that people might prefer stories that feel like their own.

Sunday, 8 November 2026

AN UN-COOPERATIVE PERPETRATOR

There are moments in public life when the universe, with its customary lack of consideration for political convenience, simply refuses to cooperate. The recent unpleasantness in Kraków’s main square was one such moment. A young man, having first disposed of his own family with a thoroughness that suggested personal rather than ideological motive, proceeded to the historic centre of the city and opened fire upon strangers. Six people died; more than a dozen others were injured. The event was tragic, random, and—in the particular way that modern atrocities often are—immediately annexed by politicians who had been waiting for precisely this sort of opportunity.

Donald Tusk, never one to let a crisis go to waste, moved with the speed of a man who has already decided the moral of the story before the blood has dried. The perpetrator, we were informed with impressive certainty, was an ultranationalist, a far-right extremist, a man whose radical views placed him in uncomfortable proximity to those awkward patriotic and conservative forces currently making life difficult for Tusk's pals in Brussels. The narrative was neat, serviceable, and almost elegant in its simplicity. It required only one small adjustment: the disappearance of the shooter’s Facebook page.

According to reports that have the ring of the plausible, the order went out to erase the account at once. One understands the urgency. Social media, for all its vulgarity, has an inconvenient habit of preserving the self-portrait a man draws of himself when he believes no one important is watching. In this case the portrait was not of a stern Polish traditionalist burning with resentment against Brussels, Berlin, or the European Commission. It was something rather more ambiguous.

The page, before its abrupt deletion, presented a young man given to certain theatrical flourishes. There were rainbow flags. There was an aesthetic of sexual indeterminacy that would not have looked out of place in a graduate seminar on fluid identities. There were references—confirmed by those who had known him—to the pleasures of costume and painted nails. And, most deliciously of all for those who still retain some sense of Polish cultural memory, there was open mockery of Pope John Paul II, the sainted figure whose image still hangs in half the kitchens of the country and whose moral authority remains, for many, non-negotiable. It is difficult to imagine a more efficient way of disqualifying oneself from the ranks of the Polish far right. One might as well apply for membership of the Communist Party while wearing a Solidarity badge and a yarmulke.

The difficulty for Tusk is obvious; the preferred story required a clean ideological villain—preferably one who could be linked, however tenuously, to the conservative opposition led by President Karol Nawrocki and those tiresome patriots who continue to resist what they rather dramatically call the government’s soft coup, assisted by the European Commission and the German government. Instead they were presented with a young man whose digital remains suggested a different set of cultural affiliations altogether. The Facebook page did not merely fail to support the narrative; it actively sabotaged it. Deletion, under the circumstances, must have seemed the only civilised response.

One has seen this sort of thing before, of course. Politicians of a certain progressive temperament have long treated inconvenient biographical details the way a fastidious housekeeper treats a stain on the carpet: better to remove the evidence than to explain it. Tusk, in this regard, is merely following a well-trodden path. His Spanish counterpart Pedro Sánchez has elevated the practice to something approaching an art form, and both men enjoy the protective umbrella of Ursula von der Leyen’s Brussels, an institution that has never been overly troubled by the gap between proclaimed principle and operational necessity. The technique is simple: assert the preferred interpretation early and loudly, then ensure that contradictory material vanishes before too many people have time to notice.

What makes the Kraków case particularly rich in sardonic possibility is the sheer mismatch between the crime and the costume the authorities wished the criminal to wear. Killing one’s own family and then spraying bullets into a crowded square is the act of a profoundly disturbed individual. It is not, however, the characteristic gesture of the Polish ultranationalist, a type who, whatever his other failings, tends to revere the family, the nation, and the late Pope with equal fervour. The Facebook evidence suggested someone more at home in the overlapping worlds of performative identity and private fantasy than in the stern barracks of the radical right. To insist otherwise required either heroic self-deception or a readiness to delete the evidence. The government, it appears, chose the latter.

There is a larger comedy here, and not a particularly subtle one. Europe’s political class has spent years constructing an elaborate taxonomy of threats in which the far right occupies the central place of honour. Every act of violence must, if possible, be fitted into that taxonomy. When the facts refuse to cooperate, the facts are adjusted. The result is a kind of ideological taxidermy: the specimen is stuffed, mounted, and labelled according to the requirements of the display case, regardless of what the creature actually looked like when it was alive. In Kraków the taxidermists were simply a little too hasty. They ordered the removal of the only photograph that showed the creature in its natural habitat.

One need not romanticise the opposition to see the absurdity. The conservative and patriotic forces in Poland may be as imperfect as any other political tribe. But to suggest that a young man who ridiculed John Paul II and flew the rainbow flag was somehow their spiritual representative is to stretch credulity beyond the point where it snaps and begins to laugh. The laughter, in this case, is not particularly kind. It is the dry, slightly weary amusement of someone who has watched the same performance too many times: the rush to judgment, the selective presentation of evidence, the quiet disappearance of anything that complicates the script.

In the end the dead remain dead, the wounded remain wounded, and the political class continues its endless struggle to make reality conform to theory. The Facebook page is gone, or so we are told. Yet the absurdity it revealed lingers, like the faint smell of nail varnish in a room that was supposed to smell of gun oil and nationalist fervour. One almost feels a certain sympathy for the propagandists. It is hard work, after all, trying to force the universe to take sides. The universe, as usual, declines the invitation.