Let us, for a moment, imagine a world where the Marvel Cinematic Universe, that great clanking juggernaut of spandex and CGI, has finally run out of puff. A world where the superheroes hang up their capes, the villains retire to grow begonias, and the audience is spared yet another two-hour sermon on the virtues of punching things very hard while looking noble. Captain America: Brave New World, alas, is not that film. Instead, it’s the latest dispatch from the franchise’s tireless assembly line, a movie so determined to be significant that it forgets, somewhere along the way, to be interesting.
Anthony Mackie, bless him, steps into the star-spangled boots of Sam Wilson, the new Captain America, inheriting the shield and the burden of living up to Steve Rogers, a man so wholesome he could have been baked in a pie. Mackie’s Sam is a different beast—not super-soldiered, not serum-enhanced, just a chap with a jetpack, a vibranium frisbee, and a grin that says, “I’m doing my best here, folks.”
It’s a valiant effort, and Mackie carries it off with the kind of charisma that could charm a tax auditor, but the script—credited to a committee of five, which explains a lot—seems unsure whether he’s meant to be a hero, a social worker, or a straight man in a buddy cop flick with Danny Ramirez’s chirpy Joaquin Torres, the new Falcon. The result is a character arc flatter than a Kansas prairie, interrupted only by the occasional mid-air twirl to remind us he’s got wings.
Then there’s Harrison Ford, rumbling onto the scene as President Thaddeus “Thunderbolt” Ross, a man who spends half the film growling about treaties and the other half turning into the Red Hulk, presumably because someone at Marvel thought, “What if we made him angry and gave him a dye job?” Ford, now in his ninth decade of looking grumpy on screen, plays Ross with the weary gravitas of a man who’d rather be fishing, and who can blame him? The plot—a labyrinthine tangle of assassinations, mind control, and something about a Celestial island full of adamantium—feels like it was stitched together from the cutting-room floor of better Captain America films, notably The Winter Soldier, whose paranoid-thriller vibes this one mimics without ever matching. Ford’s transformation into a crimson behemoth is the film’s big money shot, spoiled months ago by trailers, and when it arrives, it’s less a shock than a shrug—an eight-minute tantrum that suggests Marvel’s idea of escalation is to make the Hulk look like he’s been dipped in ketchup.
The villains, such as they are, include Tim Blake Nelson as the Leader, a gamma-irradiated brainiac with a forehead so swollen it could double as a parade float. Nelson chews the scenery with gusto, but his evil plan—something about revenge and probability—never quite gels into a threat worth caring about. Giancarlo Esposito pops up as Sidewinder, a mercenary so underused he might as well be credited as “Guy Who Frowns in Background,” and Shira Haas’s Ruth Bat-Seraph, a former Black Widow turned presidential aide, gets one decent fight scene before fading into expository wallpaper. It’s a rogue’s gallery that feels less menacing than mildly inconveniencing, like a queue at the post office.
The action, to be fair, has its moments. Sam’s shield-and-wing combos are crisply choreographed, and there’s a certain glee in watching him surf a missile for five glorious seconds before the film remembers it’s meant to be serious. But for every tidy punch-up, there’s a CGI slog—green-screen backdrops so clunky they make you pine for the days of matte paintings and men in rubber suits. The climax, a predictable showdown with Ross’s Red Hulk, is loud and long and utterly devoid of stakes, a reminder that in the MCU, nothing ever really ends, it just pauses for the next instalment.
What’s most exasperating about Brave New World is its refusal to take a swing at anything meaningful. It flirts with big ideas—Sam as a Black Captain America, the legacy of Isaiah Bradley (Carl Lumbly, the film’s quiet MVP), the murk of American power—but retreats into platitudes and explosions before it can say anything sharp. This is a film that wants to be Winter Soldier with a social conscience, but it’s too busy nodding to Eternals and The Incredible Hulk—Marvel’s equivalent of dusting off old photo albums—to find its own voice. By the time Kendrick Lamar’s “I” blares over the credits, you’re left wondering if the real brave new world is one where Marvel dares to let a movie stand alone, unburdened by the weight of 35 predecessors.
In the end, Captain America: Brave New World is neither triumph nor disaster, just a serviceable pit stop in the MCU’s endless road trip. Mackie deserves better, Ford deserves a nap, and we, the audience, deserve a breather. But the machine grinds on, and so must we, until the next one rolls around. At least the popcorn’s still good.