In the year of our Lord 2026, the proposition that James Bond still makes any coherent sense has become one of those charming cultural anachronisms, like the idea that a man might still light a woman’s cigarette without first submitting a risk assessment form in triplicate. The original observation was simple enough: from his very first mission, the modern state would be far too busy trying to put 007 behind bars to bother with whatever SPECTRE was cooking up this week. Bond himself would scarcely dare attempt a seduction, lest some retrospective withdrawal of consent turn the entire enterprise into a matter for the Crown Prosecution Service and a carefully worded apology from the Foreign Office. That was the starting point. Events have since conspired to give the thought a rather larger canvas.
Robert Pattinson has been named the next James Bond, and one must begin by wishing him well. The man can act. After the adolescent vampire nonsense of his early fame, he has spent the intervening years accumulating a body of work that is frequently odd, frequently intense, and frequently better than the material deserved. There is a restless intelligence there, a willingness to look slightly unwell or slightly unhinged on camera that is not to be sniffed at. One does not doubt that he will approach the role with the same seriousness he has brought to other unlikely assignments. Seriousness, however, is precisely the problem.
Denis Villeneuve is to direct. Villeneuve is a gifted filmmaker whose gift runs almost exclusively toward the sombre, the atmospheric, and the deliberately unhurried. His films tend to treat narrative as a secondary consideration to mood, and mood as something best achieved by lingering on vast landscapes while the human figures within them look quietly tormented by the weight of existence. Applied to James Bond, this aesthetic raises the possibility that we shall be treated to a two-and-a-half-hour meditation on the loneliness of the licensed killer, punctuated by the occasional muted explosion and a great deal of meaningful silence. The famous quips may survive, but one suspects they will be delivered in the manner of a man who has just read Camus and is not entirely sure the joke is funny any more. The result threatens to be an emasculated Bond: competent, haunted, and carefully divested of the cheerful, almost adolescent swagger that once made the character both absurd and irresistible.
Fans, those tiresome people who still remember what the character was for, had rather hoped for Henry Cavill. Cavill possesses the sort of physical presence that makes the tuxedo look like a natural extension of the man rather than a costume carefully fitted by a nervous wardrobe department. He has the shoulders for it, the jaw for it, and the unapologetic air of a chap who would order the martini without first checking whether the vermouth had been ethically sourced. Paired with someone like Sydney Sweeney as a classic, voluptuous Bond girl—someone who looked as though she had wandered in from a more generous era of cinema rather than a contemporary casting call determined to demonstrate progressive credentials—the combination might have restored a certain old-fashioned pleasure to the proceedings. The eyes of the audience, at least the portion of the audience that still prefers its spies glamorous rather than guilt-ridden, would have recognised the arrangement at once.
Instead, the rumour mill has begun to turn in a more contemporary direction. Among the names floated for the next Bond “girl” is Hunter Schafer. One notes the inverted commas with a certain weary precision, because the word itself is already under quiet renegotiation. The suggestion is offered, in the usual quarters, as a bold and historic step. Historic it may well be. Whether it is wise is another matter entirely. Bond’s relationships with women have always been the most vulnerable part of the formula, easily reduced to caricature or offence. To treat the role of the Bond girl as an opportunity for contemporary social signalling rather than for the particular, slightly ridiculous glamour the series once specialised in is to risk turning the entire enterprise into an exercise in careful messaging. The horror is not personal; it is aesthetic. One does not wish to watch James Bond negotiating pronouns while the villain waits patiently for the scene to finish.
The deeper difficulty remains the one that opened this discussion. The character was conceived in a world that still believed, however naively, that a certain kind of ruthless competence in the service of the realm was worth celebrating. That world has been replaced by one in which competence itself is frequently treated as a form of privilege, and ruthlessness as something requiring immediate therapeutic intervention. Bond’s licence to kill would today be accompanied by a thick file of risk assessments, diversity targets, and mandatory training modules on unconscious bias. His tendency to sleep with the opposition would trigger an investigation before the sheets had cooled. The government that once sent him out would now spend most of its energy trying to explain why it had ever employed such a liability in the first place.
Pattinson may yet surprise us. Actors of talent sometimes do. Villeneuve may discover a previously concealed appetite for the pure, unapologetic nonsense that Bond requires. Stranger things have happened in the history of popular entertainment. Yet the surrounding climate makes such an outcome look less like a probability and more like a faint hope. The franchise has survived changes of actor, changes of tone, and even the occasional change of century. Whether it can survive the determination of the present age to sand every sharp edge off its heroes is a more open question.
One watches the forthcoming production with a mixture of residual curiosity and the quiet certainty that the real drama will take place not on the screen, but in the careful negotiations that precede every frame.